Former Bengals WR Jerome Simpson's split-second decision to jump over Cardinals LB Daryl Washington on Christmas Eve, 2011, turned a mundane catch into an unbelievable 19-yard touchdown, and a play that will make Simpson forever a part of NFL lore. Michael Nyerges, Cincinnati Enquirer
The one moment when execution, skill, spontaneity and a whole lot of magic can mix together to create a legend. Over the last 30 years there have been hundreds of incredible individual plays by Bengals players. We wanted to pinpoint the top five. Everyone has an opinion.