Scott Cassidy had a decision to make.
Le Moyne College, the team for which Cassidy coached, held onto a three-run lead early in the 2017 season. But despite Josiah Gray owning an 8.31 ERA across the 8 2/3 innings, he pitched as a freshman, Cassidy turned to the sophomore in a critical position.
Gray, recruited as a two-way player, had already clubbed the go-ahead three-run homer earlier in the game. He needed four outs to secure the win when he took the mound.