The Toronto Blue Jays were looking to add a third Commissioners Trophy to their trophy case this season, but came up just short. But there were plenty of guys on the roster who were up for some individual hardware as well.
George Springer walked away with a Silver Slugger award, as announced live and exclusively on The Baseball Insiders YouTube channel. Springer took home the award for his production as a Designated Hitter in 2025, and was completely deserving of the honour. However, there was another Blue Jay who appeared to be a lock for a different award, but got beat out completely unexpectedly.