This offseason, the Toronto Blue Jays have some key players from their 2025 roster heading into free agency. Whether they were role players or elite stars on the team, each and every one of them made an impact on the successful season and postseason run that the Blue Jays had this past year.
However, not all of them will likely be back for another go-around in 2026, whether due to need or potential financial hurdles. As a result, Toronto will need to be selective in who they want to retain.
Ranking the 6 Blue Jays free agents by who Toronto would want back the most
#6 Isiah Kiner-Falefa
Despite his second go-around with Toronto not being as impactful and impressive as his first in 2024, Kiner-Falefa was nevertheless looked upon frequently by Jays manager John Schneider to come off the bench down the stretch and into the playoffs.