Back to the Toronto Blue Jays Newsfeed

Five snubs from MLB on FOX's Blue Jays all-time All-Star team

It's that time of year again when MLB's best come together in Atlanta for the 95th All-Star Game. It's also the unofficial halfway point for any MLB season, as playoff races get tighter for October baseball.
MLB on FOX recently put out an all-time lineup for every team in the league. Their all-time Toronto Blue Jays lineup looks like this:

From franchise icons to fan favorites, here’s the Blue Jays all-time lineup. Did we get it right? pic.twitter.com/eQCqX4ljPi

— FOX Sports: MLB (@MLBONFOX) July 10, 2025

While their take on the best Blue Jays lineup is already elite with the likes of Roy Halladay, Joe Carter, and Tony Fernandez, that begs the question: Who also deserved to be mentioned in Toronto's all-time lineup?