Tennessee has never been great at keeping in-state talent playing for the Vols. Recent names that come to mind are Tee Higgins (Clemson WR) and Cade Mays (Georgia OT). Others in the past include Jalen Ramsey (Florida State CB), Marlon Brown (Georgia WR).
On the basketball side of things, the Vols missed out on five-star prospect Darius Garland (Vanderbilt) last season. Other players that come to mind were combo guard Shai Gilgeous-Alexander (Kentucky), Braxton Key (Alabama), and Alex Poythress (Kentucky).
Now I fairness, Jordan Bone was the 5th highest rated recruit in the 2016 class. Five-star Robert Hubbs was the top-ranked recruit in 2013.