McMahon played the majority of his career in the 1990s, but he qualified for this because he played his senior season in 2000. McMahon was a very talented quarterback and his cause is obviously hurt because he played on some terrible teams. But I just can't justify picking McMahon over Mike Teel, who had better career stats and was at the commands for Rutgers' most successful stretch ever.
Sanu was the single toughest omission from the All-Millenium Team. It's a testament to the quality of receivers Rutgers has churned out in the 2000s that Sanu wasn't a lock.