Player ratings: NYCFC 2-3 RSL

Brad Penner-USA TODAY SportsNick Rimando - 5.5 I don't remember very many particularly impressive saves from Rimando. He made a few stops in the first half, but mostly, NYC was off target. He nearly got a PK save on David Villa and you could tell he wanted it back.

Demar Phillips - 6 Phillips was pretty sharp, but was getting caught in some tough spots when NYC was pressuring.

Justen Glad - 5.5 Glad had a pretty decent night and was unlucky on the nutmeg goal, but it was a vast improvement from the Columbus game.

Aaron Maund - 5.5 Our CBs were not what I would call air tight on defense. Too many easy chances were coming for New York. On a positive note, Maund and Glad seem to be communicating…