All season long Brotherly Game polled the fans and tallied the "wisdom of the crowd" to determine which players were most important and which players were screwing things up. We've also tracked the expert ratings from Adam Cann and Co. at Philly Soccer Page and the statistically based algorithm created by Whoscored. Who was the best player? Who struggled the most? Let's dig in.
Best and worst games
Here's a look at the scores of each system by game:
The Whoscored rating doesn't show much volatility but the scale of that score is much tighter, generally ranging between 6 and 8.