Millersville was 20 minutes way from a win in regulation and 75 seconds away from a third straight penalty shootout when two goals from the University Charleston sank their hopes of a return to trip to the NCAA Division II final four for the first time in a decade.
The Marauders led 1-0 on a goal from Richy Valverde in the 42nd minute off an assist from Bobby Hennessy and they were able to hold it until Adrian Camacho was fouled in the box and Gabriel Rodriguez leveled the score with a penalty kick in the 71st minute.