When it comes to reminiscing on former Phillies greats, the word “overrated” is rarely a term thrown around by fans. It’s simply far more fun to reflect back and point out all the underrated ex-Phils who donned the red and white pinstripes. Especially when it comes to the championship squads of 1980 and 2008, it’s hard to really pin anyone as “overrated.”
However, reality is often disappointing. While the Phillies have had their fair share of all-time greats come through the city over the years, they’ve also had their fair share of overrated players come through.