Jeremiah Smith, Kayden McDonald, Arvell Reese and Caleb Downs are consensus All-Americans, and Carson Hinzman will also receive a tree in Buckeye Grove.
Smith, McDonald, Reese and Downs all officially became consensus All-Americans on Tuesday as they were named first-team All-Americans by the American Football Coaches Association.
All of them were already named first-team All-Americans by the Walter Camp Football Foundation and Associated Press, making them consensus All-Americans. Each of them would become a unanimous All-American if named first-team All-Americans by Sporting News and the Football Writers Association of America, which will announce their All-America teams on Wednesday and Thursday, respectively.