With the first round of the NFL Draft in the books, experts everywhere have put out their night one draft grades, assessing the quality of teams’ choices. Two Northwestern players — tackle Rashawn Slater and cornerback Greg Newsome II — heard their names called on Thursday, so here’s a breakdown of how their selections have fared in the eyes of the draft punditry.

Rashawn Slater

Selected 13th overall by the Los Angeles Chargers

SB Nation’s James Dator — A-

The Ringer’s Danny Kelly — A+

The Draft Network’s Ryan Fowler — A

NFL.