NC State Redshirt Senior Quarterback Grayson McCall has been named to the 2024 Comeback Player of the Year Watch List. McCall is 1 of 89 players on the Watch List.
| PLAYER | SCHOOL | Conference | POSITION |
| Zuberi Mobley | FAU | AAC | RB |
| Ikaika Ragsdale | North Texas | AAC | RB |
| Jason Vaughn | Univ. South Florida (USF) | AAC | DE |
| Blake Horvath | Navy | AAC | QB |
| Kenneth McShan | Navy | AAC | LB |
| Bryce Steele | Boston College | ACC | LB |
| Cole Turner | Clemson | ACC | WR |
| Eli Pancol | Duke | ACC | WR |
| Leo Blackburn | Georgia Tech | ACC | WR |
| Sylvain Yondjouen | Georgia Tech | ACC | DL |
| Ja’Corey Brooks | Louisville | ACC | WR |
| Tyler Shough | Louisville | ACC | QB |
| Emory Williams | Miami | ACC | QB |
| Grayson McCall | NC State | ACC | QB |
| Trebor Pena | Syracuse | ACC | WR |
| Oronde Gadsden II | Syracuse | ACC | TE |
| Kobe Paysour | UNC | ACC | WR |
| CJ Harris | California | ACC | QB |
| Kam Butler | Virginia | ACC | DE |
| Nick Gallo | Virginia Tech | ACC | TE |
| Ali Jennings | Virginia Tech | ACC | WR |
| Donavon Greene | Wake Forest | ACC | WR |
| Zakhari Franklin | Illinois | Big Ten | WR |
| Josh McCray | Illinois | Big Ten | RB |
| Solomon Vanhorse | Indiana | Big Ten | RB |
| Cade McNamara | Iowa | Big Ten | QB |
| Luke Lachey | Iowa | Big Ten | TE |
| Tyneil Hopper | Michigan State | Big Ten | TE |
| Darnell Jefferies | Minnesota | Big Ten | DL |
| Gabe Ervin, Jr. |