He has been widely praised for the work he has done at Newcastle, despite little backing from owner Mike Ashley, and most fans seem eager for him to stay on as manager if a much-mooted takeover goes ahead.
But questions are starting to be asked about the Spaniard and his tactics after a woeful run of form.
The Magpies have lost four Premier League matches in a row and the manner of their latest loss - a 3-0 reverse at home to Watford - has led some to question whether Benitez is getting too much of an easy ride at St James' Park.