Kyle Tucker or Cody Bellinger has been a debate that has been raging among the New York Yankees community all winter. Both players have cases to be made in their favor, with some preferring Bellinger thanks to his standout 2025 showing in New York, while others point out that anything Bellinger does, Tucker can do better.
Of course, it's not as simple as choosing one over the other, as the Yankees' true desires might simply be to lower payroll, making a deal with either in-demand outfielder simply unfeasible.
If we assume, though, that the Yankees will spend enough to land one of these big fish, then the question becomes which is the better value.