The Yankees have had 14 different players win the MVP award. Of the 14, seven are Hall of Famers, and one will be (Aaron Judge). It's an embarrassment of riches for the most successful franchise in sports history, notwithstanding what could become the longest stretch without a title if this goes beyond 2026.
Trying to rank the greatest Yankee MVPs is like ranking the Avengers. But we're going to attempt it anyway as fans ride the high of Judge's generational run atop Major League Baseball with Shohei Ohtani.
Complete history of New York Yankees' MVP winners, ranked
Spud Chandler (1943)
Spud Chandler is the only Yankees pitcher to win the MVP award, and he did so before the introduction of the Cy Young Award in 1956.