The history of playoff baseball is as much about the haunting defeats as the unforgettable moments and victories. Picking one play that haunts fans is pretty much impossible, but like the people who eat candy corn, let's do something we shouldn't do and choose one.
First, however, here are a few plays that fell short of making the cut:
1986 World Series
Bill Buckner's error
First, the New York Mets had already tied the game. Second, the Boston Red Sox could have still won Game 7 (and led 3-0 in the sixth inning).