The baseball world has had a few days to digest New York Yankees superstar Aaron Judge winning his third MVP, but some people still aren't having it. The idea that Seattle Mariners star Cal Raleigh had the best season for a catcher ever, yet still fell short of Judge, continues to bother fans and pundits alike, including popular sportscaster Dan Patrick.
On a new episode of The Dan Patrick Show, Patrick set up an interesting theoretical situation to argue that Raleigh deserved MVP. While it was a more compelling stance than other pro-Raleigh arguments, it still wasn't completely convincing.