With so many star-studded rosters throughout the years, the New York Yankees have had their fair share of representation in the All-Star Game. With so many all-time legends donning pinstripes throughout the franchise's history, most were incredibly deserving.
With that said, looking back through history, there are a select few where one has to stop and scratch their head. Wait! That guy was an All-Star?
Those moments are few and far between, but they do exist. These six players are the worst Yankees to ever make an All-Star team. Some would have success elsewhere, whereas others never really deserved the honor.