Right-handed pitcher Cam Tilly dominated in baseball while attending Castle High School in Newburgh, Indiana. Throwing a fastball that touched the mid-90s and pairing it with a great slider and decent curveball and changeup, he posted a 0.51 ERA and struck out 225 batters over the course of the three years he played varsity baseball for the Knights. Additionally, he was a star quarterback as well, though he gave up football during his junior season of school to focus on baseball, more specifically, to have time to play for the U18 USA National Team. Considered one of the best players in Indiana available in the 2023 MLB Draft, and among the upper echelons of high school pitchers, there where whispers that the right-hander might get picked as a mid-Day 2 overslot prepster, but his name was never called.
2025 Mets Draft profile: Cam Tilly
