If you were going to create a New York Giants’ version of Mount Rushmore, who would be the four faces you’d put up there? That’s a tough task, considering the franchise has been in existence for 93 years, has 31 Hall of Famers associated with it has and retired the numbers of twelve players.
I narrowed it down by throwing a ton of names on the wall and see who stuck. The criteria was also simplified by favoring players who played for the club exclusively during their careers and yes, longevity counts. Throw in the individual’s overall persona and standing in league history.