When I was a child there was a popular TV show called, “To Tell the Truth.” Four celebrity judges would be introduced to a group of three people, one of whom had something unusual about them that the panel would be told in advance, while the others were impostors. The job of the judges was to figure out via questioning which one was the actual person they’d been told about and which were the impostors.
That’s what predicting the New York Giants’ 2024 record feels like. Was the 2022 team, which unexpectedly reached the Divisional Round of the NFL playoffs, the real Brian Daboll-era team?