Not every draft pick is going to pan out. For all the recent praise New York Giants general manager Joe Schoen has received for modernizing the franchise, his track record in the draft is still a mixed bag. The big swings haven’t always connected, and some of his earliest picks are trending dangerously close to bust territory.
Several Schoen draft picks are now fighting for their futures with Big Blue. Some were once expected to grow into starters, while others were late-round flyers just hoping to stick. With the 2025 season around the corner, the reality is setting in: not every pick is going to pan out.