Bleacher Report's Kristopher Knox published Every Teams Mt. Rushmore Since 2000. The 4 Saints selected on this list were Drew Brees, Marques Colston, Jahri Evans, and Cameron Jordan. This list consisted of players only, which is why Sean Payton was not selected.
Three of the four players to make this list all joined the Saints in 2006, and were a major pieces of their 2009 Super Bowl campaign. Cameron Jordan would come into the picture years later in 2011.
The Saints have seen so many great players put on their uniform since the turn of the century, but Knox believes that creating this list was very simple.