Isaac Constans: I prefer Jamal Murray. While I have no questions about the scoring prowess of Buddy, you see what you get. You know that Buddy Buckets will find a way to translate his point-scoring talent to the NBA, but the size and physicality differences will limit his effectiveness doing so. And for a 6'4 senior, there is less adjustment room in his game to develop in other areas.
Murray, meanwhile, was not obviously half the college scorer that Hield was, but that was in one year. In his brief stint at the one-and-done academy of Kentucky, Murray was an especially effective shooter and showed windows of potential all over the offensive end.