It is always difficult to know the inner-workings of a professional sports organisation. They are inherently private, either keen to protect those that are underperforming or hide those whose work is successful such that other organisations cannot replicate their processes.
As a result, it is always a little testing and uncomfortable to heavily criticise their decision-making behind closed doors. You never know the full picture. You never have all the information, the entire context, to completely analyse the situation.
Nevertheless, sometimes questions must be asked. Sometimes, the decisions made are that strange and detrimental that scrutiny and criticism is deserved.