This debate was a topic of discussion on last week's Baseball Tonight podcast with Buster Olney: Would you rather have a lineup of eight 25-homer players or eight Gold Glovers? Fun question. With eight 25-homer dudes you're going to hit 200 home runs, although 200 home runs isn't what it used to be -- 11 teams reached that figure in 2018. The Gold Glove team is going to be brilliant on defense, but you have no idea what kind of offense they bring to the table.
Buster, Tim Kurkjian and myself went with the Gold Glovers.