Miami Dolphins quarterback Jay Cutler has been the target of so hundreds, maybe thousands of internet memes that almost always show him with a never-changing casual expression on his face. Long known for a "Don't care" demeanor, it turns out there is an alleged story behind how that came about.
A few years ago while Cutler was with the Chicago Bears, he was in the bathroom of a trendy sushi restaurant when a fan approached him while he was at the urinal. The fan started to talk to Cutler, saying he too was a Vanderbilt alumnus, so maybe they might know some of the same people.