Well, basically, that is what we all are in some form or another. I know that I have often thought, damn, I can do it better than he can, or what is he thinking? Armchair GM’s also usually feel they are good managers too.
Over the last several years, I have often disagreed with both Roberts and AF. I still feel Roberts, although a great communicator and player’s manager, still plays favorites sometimes and sticks with his player, even when the player’s skill’s or production have deteriorated. I still also believe he is not a great or even very good baseball strategist.