According to PFF, the Indianapolis Colts have around a league average running back room headed into the 2025 campaign—even with star Jonathan Taylor returning, coming in at just 16th overall:
16. Indianapolis Colts
Jonathan Taylor has suddenly become one of the toughest backs in football to evaluate. He rebounded on the surface with a 1,400-yard rushing season in 2024, but he earned a career-low 57.1 PFF overall grade due to an inability to break tackles.
The Colts added Khalil Herbert in free agency to back up Taylor, but he is coming off a career-worst season, as well.