According to PFF, the Indianapolis Colts’ top three players ahead of the 2025 campaign are as follows:
INDIANAPOLIS COLTS
OG QUENTON NELSON
OT BERNHARD RAIMANN
DI DEFOREST BUCKNER
Nelson holds the highest WAR for any non-quarterback on the Colts, both in 2024 (0.55) and as a three-year average (0.44). Raimann delivered career highs across the board — 85.1 overall grade, 82.0 pass-blocking grade and 80.7 run-blocking grade. Buckner earned an 81.9 overall grade, extending his streak to three consecutive seasons above 80.