According to PFF, former Indianapolis Colts All-Pro punter Pat McAfee, who of course is now a highly successful mainstream sports and entertainment media personality, is the best player at his old football position over the past 25 years:
PUNTER: Pat McAfee (95.3 Career Punt Grade)
McAfee is the highest-graded punter of the PFF era by a significant margin, with the next closest player being AJ Cole (89.3). That six-point gap is the largest of any position on this list.
McAfee’s 4.54-second average hangtime on 611 qualifying punts is a top-five mark all time among qualifying punters, and he added 214 punts that landed inside the opponent’s 20-yard line.