Between a new starting quarterback, an inconsistent supporting cast, and a team still trying to figure out its identity, the Indianapolis Colts enter the 2025 season with countless on-field question marks. That uncertainty could be tricky for fantasy football managers who must decide which Colts are worth using on their teams and which are better left alone.
Eight Indianapolis players and the team’s defense are ranked inside ESPN’s top 300 in fantasy, but none of them are safe bets. Some could be standouts, while others could be complete busts.
If you play fantasy football and are looking to strike gold, the Indianapolis roster is full of high-risk, high-reward options.