Pettitte isn’t even a borderline case. But he SHOULD be

Photo by Sporting News via Getty Images/Sporting News via Getty Images via Getty ImagesWhile reading Theo’s article on Pettitte, Buehler, and Hudson evaluation for the Hall of Fame, I started to comment on the bottom my frustration. Not with his article or it’s premise, but the need for the Hall of Fame to do something differently with their voting.

I decided I would go back to look at 6 Hall of Fame cases. I’ll keep Pettitte as the known entity to show why I don’t believe Pettitte is even a borderline case for the Hall of Fame, but why I think he should be, and some players who I believe to be crazy oversights.

Pettitte’s “case” generally is of an above average pitcher with an long tenure,…