We disagree on things as a fanbase. It is normal. Something that one person believes is great is viewed as utter trash by another. Beauty is in the eye of the beholder and therefore our opinions on things differ from time to time. Again, that is to be expected.
One of the most divisive issues among Dallas Cowboys fans specifically is always the quarterback who plays for the team. This is true of Dak Prescott, was true of Tony Romo before him and will be true for all of time. Unless you are lifting Lombardi Trophies you are subject to ridicule.