It was Columbus Crew SC’s 23rd birthday on Thursday, an unhappy birthday after Wednesday evening’s U.S. Open Cup loss to FC Cincinnati. There is an anger borne out of a game where Columbus started a strong side, controlled the match and had the better opportunities, but still lost on a herculean individual effort by Djiby Fall and a stout defense.
But it’s an anger that also goes beyond performance on the field.
A similar loss to Miami FC or Sacramento Republic, both “Cupset” victors over MLS sides on Wednesday, would have shaken the fans, but the effects would have been more muted.