23. Mitchell Kilkenny (141 points, 15 ballots)
Thus far in his professional career, Mitchell Kilkenny has pitched well across three different levels after overcoming some injury adversity. The adversity in Kilkenny’s case came from a post-draft physical which discovered Colorado’s 2018 second rounder needed Tommy John surgery immediately. The 6’3” pitcher returned in time for a brief spell in rookie ball in 2019, then lost 2020 like almost every other prospect as the Rockies didn’t prioritize him for the alternate site despite his draft pedigree.
Mid-season 2021 Rank: 21
High Ballot: 10
Mode Ballot: 24
Future Value: 35+, 5th/6th starter
Contract Status: 2018 2nd Round, Rule 5 eligible, three options remaining
When drafted, Kilkenny (who will turn 25 next week) had the profile of a “pitchability righty” in scouting parlance.