Most would say that heading to arbitration is never the right move for a team and a player just because of the animosity it causes in relationships.
However, in the case of Tyson Barrie, arbitration should be the only option if they can’t sign him long-term.
When a player goes to arbitration, management gets to decide whether or not they want the contract awarded to be for one year or two years.
The Colorado Avalanche will almost certainly choose the two year option if they make it to the hearing without a deal already in place.