Back to the Cleveland Guardians Newsfeed

Who is your favorite Cleveland Indians player? How about some strange picks -- Terry Pluto (video, photos)

CLEVELAND, Ohio -- In the name of Karl Pagel, who was your favorite Cleveland Indians player?

That's right, Karl Pagel ... not Mike Pagel.

Mike Pagel was the Cleveland Browns quarterback. Karl Pagel -- nickname of PONGO -- was with the Indians briefly when I covered them for The Plain Dealer in the early 1980s.

The PD's Ginger Christ and I talk about our favorite players in this video.

There are some big names -- Omar Vizquel and Rocky Colavito.

But there are some strange ones, too.

Including one pitcher who disappeared in Alaska and used to put dead rodents in his teammates lockers.