When Bo Naylor was called up to the major league roster in 2023 for everyday reps, many hoped he would be the answer to the many struggles the catcher position was harboring.
Instead, the Cleveland Guardians would have their issues at the plate only magnified further.
The tandem of Naylor and veteran Austin Hedges have kept a strong hold on the defensive metrics, but the bats have gone silent. With the American League Central race remaining highly contested, Cleveland faces a critical question: Is it time to look another direction at catcher?
Once hyped as a future cornerstone catcher, Naylor has endured offensive disappointment.