Over the past six seasons, there have been 11 players who have played for both the Guardians and Pirates.
That list of 11 players ranges from the forgotten (Cody Bolton and Yohan Ramírez) to a free agent prize (Josh Bell). And although the Pirates finished last season 71-91, they still have some intriguing talent who could help the Guardians win in 2026.
Enter Johan Oviedo.
While Oviedo’s career ERA of 4.24 doesn’t jump off the page, The Athletic’s Ken Rosenthal broke down his value as a “hidden gem” (subscription required) while writing that the Pirates would consider moving him in exchange for the right position player return.