Cleveland Indians All-Time Team: Shortstop

We are celebrating the history of the Cleveland Indians franchise by selecting the all-time team. In this installment, we select the all-time shortstop.

I don’t usually go into these selections with any assumptions. I tend to let the data speak for itself, but on this one, I was operating under the assumption that I would use Omar Vizquel as my shortstop. The more I dive into the history of Cleveland Indians shortstops, the more unsure I was about picking Omar.

By the time I got deep into every possible candidate, the waters were so muddy that I had no clue who was the right choice. In fact, I was surprised at how many fantastic shortstops have played for the Cleveland Indians.

Before I go…