Fansided · Oct 20, 2025
3 Guardians hitters who somehow never won a Silver Slugger
Cleveland Indians v Baltimore Orioles | Rob Carr/GettyImagesWhile the Cleveland Guardians have had plenty of players win Silver Sluggers since the award’s inception in 1980, that doesn’t mean that every slugger to suit up for the team has had their feats represented with a Silver Slugger win.
Here are three former Cleveland sluggers who put together great seasons that resulted in a Silver Slugger snub.
These three Guardians put together great seasons that didn’t win a Silver Slugger
Travis Hafner - 2006