The MLB site experts at FanSided recently got together for a mock Hall of Fame vote. After all 42 ballots were cast, only one player emerged to be immortalized in Cooperstown. No surprise, that player was Derek Jeter. Former Cincinnati Reds third baseman Scott Rolen received some love from the site experts, but not enough to make the cut.
The site experts adhered to BBWAA voting rules, with 10 players maximum per ballot and a 75 percent voting threshold to be elected. There were mixed opinions on those players accused of used PEDs.