2010 1st round pick: Jermaine Gresham, TE
Grade: C+
Gresham was a two time Pro Bowler, but only played in the stripes for five years. Gresham had 24 touchdowns as a Bengal, which is good production from a tight end. Still, a first round pick is supposed to be a long term member of the team. With Gresham leaving for Arizona in 2015, I have his time in Cincinnati graded at a C+.
2011 1st round pick: A.J. Green, WR
Grade: A+
It is pretty obvious Green gets the highest grade on this list.