Back to the Chicago Cubs Newsfeed

Silver (Slugger) or Gold (Glove): Manny Machado vs. Addison Russell

While the Cubs appear to be fading in the Manny Machado sweepstakes, the conversation is far from over. Plus, it remains a fascinating conversation as most deals for Machado as a shortstop involve sacrificing one strength in order to gain another.

Consider that among qualified MLB shortstops, Addison Russell ranks second in Defensive Runs Saved (+10). At the other end, Manny Machado is last (-20). However, if he stays healthy and in the AL, he should win the Silver Slugger Award.

This awakens the old debate about the relative importance of strong defense at shortstop as a foundation for winning championships.