After another successful season on the Boston Red Sox's farm, we'll evaluate the best pitchers in the system by creating an all-prospect pitching staff. We'll select prospects to make up a starting rotation and bullpen, which will nicely complement our all-prospect team of position players.
We'll select a standard five-man rotation with eight relievers. To qualify, the prospects had to pitch in Single-A or above, and could not reach the majors. Unfortunately, that means Payton Tolle and Connelly Early are out of the mix, but the Red Sox still have plenty of other pitching prospects to get excited about after their work in 2025.