With the 2025 season on the cusp, the analytic outlet Pro Football Focus (PFF) has released its All-PFF team for the last 25 years of play. Hate them or swear by them, PFF has been a consistent grading platform for NFL play since they began grading games in 2006.
I find that PFF is generally pretty accurate between both trenches and offensive play, but it’s harder to accurately grade defensive plays without knowing the call — making their grading system on defensive players a little more subjective.
Either way, PFF is a respected and fun part of the NFL media space.