Reggie McNeal was drafted as a wide receiver and never saw time as a quarterback in the NFL. He briefly appeared with the Bengals in the 2006 season, carrying the ball one time for eight yards. McNeal never attempted an NFL pass and was released in September of 2007.
Like most of the other guys on this list, his collegiate career was nearly the polar opposite of his professional resume. McNeal was responsible for 59 touchdowns in four seasons at Texas A&M, a record that was broken quickly by his successor Jerrod Johnson.